Goo-Bye, Goo-Bye, Dolls Drummer Ousted In Big-Time Breakup – 1995 Interview

The Goo Goo Dolls, Buffalo’s most influential young rock band, is breaking up its original lineup after nearly a decade together. And the timing couldn’t be worse.

The band is scheduled to release a national album and single in March for Warner Bros. Records. George Tutuska, drummer for the band, says he has been forced out of the trio. Remaining members Johnny Rzeznik and Robby Takac — both guitarists — intend to continue the group, and a replacement drummer has yet to be named.

The split is causing shock waves on the Buffalo music scene.

The Goo Goo Dolls are one of the few local acts to record for a major national label and still live in the city.

They have been together since 1986, and the new album represents a crucial point in the band’s career that may determine the Goo Goo Dolls’ future as a national act.

“I’m still shocked,” a crestfallen Tutuska said in an interview with The Buffalo News this weekend.

“I didn’t leave of my own accord. Anyone who knows the band is aware of what’s going on. I put the last 10 years of my life into that band, and it really hurts. That’s all I can say.”

There has been a long-simmering dispute among the group. It had apparently been building over the past year and came to a boil this month, when Tutuska reportedly was told to leave.

“We just had differences that could not be settled,” Rzeznik said. “We’ve had a lot of heartaches and frustrations. We’ve had some good times, too, but we just couldn’t go on like this.”

Takac agreed.

“There were problems, internally, within the group,” he said. “We had a lot of uncomfortable feelings that we encountered when we all got together in the recording studio. I think a lot of it is due to the fact we’ve been together for so long.”

The split comes with the future looking bright for the band. Chris Mundy of Rolling Stone wrote in 1993 that stardom is “close at hand” for the Goo Goo Dolls. Rocker Paul Westerburg said the Dolls “have a great future.”

A Warner Bros. spokesman said, “We think the new album has a chance to be the biggest one this band has made.”

It took eight years for the Goo Goo Dolls to reach this point, and that’s an eternity for a rock band to stay together.

The Goo Goo Dolls started playing in local clubs in 1986 and won a huge following with their blue-collar, hard-driving sound. In 1989, the band produced an independent album, “Goo Goo Dolls,” that established it as one of Buffalo’s most original groups.

The Goos signed with Metal Blade Records, a subsidiary of Warner’s, and released two critically acclaimed albums, “Jed” (1989) and “Hold Me Up” (1992).

In 1993, the Goo Goo Dolls moved to the major label and released “Superstar Car Wash” for Warner. publications such as Rolling Stone, the Chicago Tribune and the Los Angeles Times raved about the album, but it failed to make a dent nationally.

Many of the Goos’ longtime fans criticized the album for being too soft and pop-oriented. Rzeznik later complained that Warner Bros. made the band change producers on the record, and decided who would produce the video. Warner Bros. also selected the first single, “We Are the Normal,” an introspective soft number instead of the band’s trademark thrash pop sound.

The failure of “Superstar” to become a big hit apparently created a tense atmosphere for the band members while they were working on the new album. Sources close to the band say there have been a number of clashes in the recording studio and ongoing battles over “differences” among group members over music and lyrics.

“The last album caused a lot of tension,” a record industry source said. “That has put more pressure on all of them for the new album. It’s a shame, because it’s a great record.”

The album, called “A Boy Named Goo,” features a much harder sound and deeper lyrics than the last one. It was produced by Lou Giordano, who has worked with such national acts as Sugar, the Smithereens and Husker Du.

The first single to be released next month is “The Only One.”

The band’s change in status could hurt the new album. The Goo Goo Dolls will have to tour and promote the album with a new lineup. Rzeznik is determined to succeed.

“We’re still really passionate about our music,” Rzeznik said. “Me and Robby are going to go on, and the label is supporting the album. We love music, and that’s the most important thing.”

Takac said: “We haven’t given up on the record. We’ll do whatever we have to to make it work. If it becomes a big hit, all of us, including George, can make money.”

The Goo Goo Dolls’ last public appearance was a New Year’s Eve show at Blind Mellons.

“It was was an emotional night for all of us,” Rzeznik said.

Both Rzeznik and Takac were in a somber mood as they talked about the split.

“We’re not happy about what happened. It has cast a dark shadow over everything, but we have to keep going,” Rzeznik said. “I wish George nothing but the best.”

Takac said the band has yet to begin its search for a drummer.

“This has all just happened. We haven’t had a chance to resolve anything,” he said. “We’re not out to dis George or anything. I know he’s not happy, but this was probably the best thing for all of us.”

Taken from here. Archived version here.

Original Goo Goo Dolls Drummer Can’t Let It Slide – 1999 Interview

Axed drummer George Tutuska talks about past with the Goo Goo Dolls; future with Bobo

Few bands have ever attained fame without making a few personnel changes along the way. Go down the list: The Beatles, Nirvana, Pearl Jam and, um, Spinal Tap, all had different members by the time their first record was certified platinum – or in the case of Tap, aluminum. Coincidentally, in all four cases, the drummers were the first to go. However, in none of the aforementioned cases did the drummer get ousted nearly a decade after he helped form the band and less than a year before they hit paydirt. That’s what happened to original Goo Goo Dolls drummer George Tutuska.

“I have no resentment toward [the Goo Goo Dolls’] continued success,” says Tutuska from his Buffalo home. “The only thing that bothers me to this very day is I never got my due as a songwriter and most people think, ‘So what, they fired the drummer; it’s just the drummer.’ If I could give people a list of songs I wrote, I think it would shock them.”

Following the completion of the Goos’ A Boy Named Goo (1995), Tutuska was fired from the band by frontman Johnny Rzeznik. Tutuska said he’d previously told band management he wouldn’t tour behind the album unless Rzeznik agreed to split royalties evenly among the three members, a practice Tutuska claims the band had engaged in since the release of their 1987 self-titled debut. During pre-production for Goo, Tutuska had been rattled to the core by news that Rzeznik purportedly was hoarding royalties for the Superstar Car Wash single “Fallin’ Down.” “I said, ‘John, I’m kinda interested. I talk to friends all over the country and everyone tells me they hear [“Fallin’ Down”] on the radio,’ and I said, ‘John, I haven’t gotten one [royalty] check for that.’ And he said, ‘I got a confession to make. I’ve been getting checks for the last two years on this song.’ And obviously, at that point, the shit hit the fan.”

Tutuska was fired from the band just shy of A Boy Named Goo’s release and replaced by Mike Malinin. The album, on the strength of the hit single “Name,” was a runaway success and has since sold one-and-a-half million copies in the U.S. alone. Though Tutuska still receives royalty checks from that album and the previous four albums, he still feels shortchanged by the perception he was merely a third wheel among the trio. “Up until A Boy Named Goo I had written probably well over half the lyrics and I collaborated on music, but we split everything,” Tutuska claims. A lot of the songs that had gotten airplay I’d written the lion’s share of, but I had taken my third and now he wanted everything.” (For the record, the Goo Goo Dolls camp had no comment on Tutuska’s allegations.)

While Tutuska concedes “no matter what I say, it can come across as sour grapes,” he has been busy juggling two careers: one as the drummer of the quintet Bobo and another as the co-owner of a home improvement company in Buffalo. “I’m not embarrassed by it,” he says. “In fact, I’m proud of it. I’m a pretty good carpenter and I do a lot of things that I’m proud of, but I really want to get back to just playing music.” Bobo (the second band Tutuska’s formed since his departure from the Goo Goo Dolls) has released a six-song EP on the Buffalo-based P22 Records. They’ve apparently also sealed a deal to contribute a song to a future USA Networks movie based on the story of Mary Kay LeTourneau, the Washington area school teacher convicted of second-degree child rape of a sixth-grade male student.

Overall, Tutuska says, “I really am a happy person and I really am an active musician so I try to concentrate on what I’m doing instead of what I’ve done.”

Taken from here. Archived version here.

Goo Goo Dolls In The House – 1993 Interview

Within a 24-hour time period last week, the Goo Goo Dolls went from a 50-member audience to a venue packed with 8,000 screaming fans. They appreciate all size crowds, but …

“I could definitely acquire a taste for large crowds,” said Goo Goo guitarist Johnny Rzeznik during a tour stop outside of the now-infamous Waco, Texas.

The Buffalo, N.Y.-based band -Rzeznik, bassist Robby Takac and drummer George Tutuska – was trying to log the last bit of an almost 2,000-mile trip and stopped for a breather. Even after six years of this, road trips don’t get easier.

“I believe traveling screws with you molecularly. You never get used to it,” said Rzeznik.

A little whining aside, he’s pretty happy with how the tour is going. He’d be happier if the Goos could sell a few more albums, though.

It took two years to get “Superstar Car Wash” out after making “Hold Me Up.”

“We had to fight with the record label, fight with our manager, fight with each other, but I’m happy with the end result,” he said.

The album, produced on Warner Bros.’ Metal Blade label, is a collection of pulsating punk pop.

No, it isn’t something you listened to and grew out of in high school. It’s what happens when late-20s guys deftly carry some of that old angst into present day and add some fine musicianship.

The thrash-laced effort received high marks from Spin and Rolling Stone, although band members feel better when doing it live.

So they tour. Rzeznik even looks forward to seeing ol’ Virginny.

“I really dig the South. It has a certain feel about it and the scenery is some of the most beautiful in the country,” he said.

The interview meandered away from music and geography and into other things going on in Rzeznik’s head.

A sample:

On groupies and such: “Monogamy is a challenge. I’m the only one married. My wife, Laurie, is totally great. She’s totally an un-rock ‘n’ roll girl, which is cool. Everybody is pretty committed to the people they have back home.”

On keeping up with world issues while touring: “I get my daily dose of negativity from CNN. It tends to slap me in the face a lot.”

On national issues: “I have a real problem with the way elderly and poor people are treated in this country.”

On industry’s treatment of consumers: “It makes sense to take care of the people who buy your products. It’s like giving a fan your autograph, you know? Yeah, I get sick of drunk people getting in my face, but it doesn’t happen all the time.”

On his favorite music: “I like Sam I Am from San Francisco and I like Irving Berlin. You don’t know a song until you’ve heard Irving Berlin.”

Taken from here. Archived version here.

The Next Big Thing After A Long, Hard Climb, Goo Goo Dolls Near The Top With ‘Superstar Car Wash’ – 1993 Article

JOHNNY RZEZNIK doesn’t drink anymore.

Johnny says he doesn’t want to be like Elvis and die face down.

You have to understand Johnny.

He’s only 27, but has been on his own for nearly half his life. His parents died when he was 15.

“I brought myself up,” Johnny says. “I had good parents, and even though they weren’t around, they were always an influence on me.” Johnny endures the pitfalls of life by adhering to his personal philosophy: “Just stay cool.”

Johnny is part of rock ‘n’ roll’s lost generation, the one that grew up in the post-Beatles, post-Stones, post-Zeppelin, classic-hits-radio wasteland.

Johnny was 12 and living in South Buffalo when he decided to become a rock ‘n’ roll star. He got turned on to music listening to the Sex Pistols. At McKinley High School and Buffalo State College, Johnny was punk personified.

Seven years ago, when Johnny was 20 and playing lead guitar, he met Robby and George. And that’s how the band Sex Maggots was born. After a number of wild incidents got the band banned from local clubs, the three of them searched for a new name. They spotted a mail-order ad in True Detective magazine selling something called a Goo Goo Doll. And that’s how the Sex Maggots became the Goo Goo Dolls.

Everybody loves Robby Takac.

It’s his goofy smile, infectious humor and outgoing personality.

Robby percolates with frenetic energy. Music has always been his outlet. As a kid, he would grab a ukulele and sing “Running Bear” while sitting in the bathtub.

Robby graduated to playing bass in a speed metal band by the time he went to West Seneca East, and continued at Medaille College.

Robby met George in college and formed a band with him. Then Robby’s cousin wanted him in a band and plotted with Robby to replace Johnny on guitar. “It was like the JFK conspiracy,” Robby says. Instead of enemies, Johnny and Robby — the two guitar rivals — became fast friends. Then George joined the posse.

“When the three of us got together, it was like a reckless regression into childhood,” Johnny says.

George is South Buffalo from his heart to his soul.

“Nothing is worth anything unless you work your a– off,” says George, who prefers not to reveal his last name.

George was supposed to be a fireman, like his father and grandfather.

He grew up in a crowded flat with his four sisters and his parents. “We didn’t have a lot of money, but I never went hungry,” George says. “We were working-class, close-knit.”

As a kid, George listened to Top 40 radio. Then, by the time he made it to Bishop Timon High School, George discovered punk. “I loved the Clash. I knew every song they made.”

George lacks Robby’s outrageous stage presence and Johnny’s rock star persona. He’s content to sit in the background and play drums with neurotic intensity. His black hair is cropped short and there is a forbidding glare in his eyes when he pounds out the beat.

“We’ve come a long way,” George says, “but we never sold out and we never gave up.”

Artie Kwitchoff knows the Goo Goo Dolls better than just about anyone else. “They’re a really strange combination,” says Kwitchoff, the band’s former manager. “Any one of the three of them could have exploded and killed the whole thing. But they stuck together, and now this band has turned into something super.”

On Feb. 23, Warner Bros. Records will release the Goo Goo Dolls’ new album, “Superstar Car Wash.” Already there are signs the record will be a smash. The band has earned positive publicity in national publications ranging from Rolling Stone to the New Yorker.

A video for the album’s first single, “We Are the Normal,” was shot in Los Angeles for MTV. One of the top producers of alternative music, Gavin MacKillop, worked on the album. The first single was co-written by Paul Westerberg of the pioneer alternative band the Replacements.

Next month the Dolls will start a national tour with Soul Asylum, one of the hottest alternative bands in the nation. After that tour ends, the Goo Goo Dolls are expected to headline their own national tour into major markets.

“Superstar Car Wash” is an alternative-pop masterpiece, layered with hooks and accessible rock ‘n’ roll. “We wanted it to be noisy,” said MacKillop. “This band writes melodic songs, but we wanted the record to have an edge. This album will give people an idea of what the Goo Goo Dolls are all about. This is not disposable pop; it’s music that says something and means something.”

“Superstar Car Wash” marks the band’s musical growth. The Dolls have long been a three-piece, power rock band in the tradition of Cream and Nirvana. Now the Goos have taken their heavy metal, punk and garage rock roots and combined them with a softer pop style. The goal was to make Goo Goo Dolls music presentable to the mainstream without compromising its integrity.

“We Are the Normal” is the most stirring example of the new Goo Goo Dolls. It features a viola solo by Mary Ramsey and an accordion riff in addition to the usual guitars and drums.

“The Goo Goo Dolls have a strong rock background, but give off a real pop feeling,” said Dennis Drew of 10,000 Maniacs. “I think the pop sound is going to help make them make the big breakthrough.”

The lyrics on the new album also reflect the band’s maturing.

“We Are the Normal” is a song of alienation and misplaced social priorities. The video was shot in the skid row section of Los Angeles, and features film of homeless and poor people as Johnny sings: “We are the normal/We live and we die/No reason why.”

“Already There” is a wailing rocker about the loss of youth and dreams. Robby sings:

“Just a boy who’s young atheart/His smile was a bit like yours today/Had a wife and kids whose strife never had to go astray/Happiness abounds, life is in full swing at 17, all the things he wanted were things he’d never seen/It don’t seem fair/’Cause I’m already there.”

At its core, “Superstar Car Wash” is an album about survival. It is a topic close to the Goo Goo Dolls because, after seven years of hunger, poverty, management turnover and tours from hell, survival is part of the act.

“Just call us the band that wouldn’t die,” Johnny says, flashing that always mischievous grin. “They tried to kill us; we tried to kill us. But we wouldn’t go away.”

It’s a cold, snowy afternoon as a visitor stands in the narrow alleyway near the side door of the North Buffalo apartment two of the Goo Goo Dolls call home. The doorbell rings and suddenly a voice echoes from a window on the second floor.

“Yo,” the voice shouts. It’s Johnny Goo’s head sticking out from under the clouds. His hair is disheveled; an earring in the shape of a cross dangles from his ear.

“I’ll be down in a minute. Wait’ll I get my pants on,” Johnny says. “I just got up.”

So it goes for the Goo Goo Dolls. Life resembles an episode from the old “Monkees” TV show: a million laughs.

Beneath that comic veneer, however, is the story of three musicians who have dedicated their lives to rock ‘n’ roll. Now they are ready to make the leap into rock’s platinum zone.

“Yeah, well, we’ve heard that all before,” says Johnny Goo. “We try to keep our expectations real. We’re not worrying about having a hit record; we’ve been through too much just to get this far.”

Back when it all began, in 1986, they were three wild kids ready to live the hedonistic rock lifestyle to the hilt. Especially when it came to drinking.

“It got to the point where we’d get up in the morning and say, ‘OK, let’s go get a 12-pack and rehearse,’ ” Robby says. “It wasn’t that we were looking to get hammered, it was just a routine we slipped into.”

Johnny, who no longer drinks, retains dark and foggy memories of those alcoholic days. “One day I woke up and realized it was just booze, booze, booze all the time. A few times we were so drunk we had to be poured on stage.

“I don’t know why it happened. I think drinking is a way of bonding for a band. You know, you got three guys and you live and work together every day. You can’t kiss each other, so you get drunk together.”

Robby is philosophical about that time. “Alcohol offered an escape. It was all part of growing up. I think 90 percent of the kids who grew up in the ’80s went through what we went through. The difference with us is that we were allowed to indulge in that stuff longer than most people because we were living in this job. It’s all part of rock ‘n’ roll.”

So are poverty, hunger and bad record deals.

That about describes the first few years of the Goo Goo Dolls’ existence.

In 1987, the Dolls scraped together $750 to make their first record on an independent label. Soon they soured on a relationship with their first manager, and had been banned from the Continental for doing damage during shows.

“If you knew them then, it was total insanity,” Kwitchoff says.

That insane attitude created a loyal local following. During shows the Dolls would run back and forth, tossing into the crowd instruments, microphones, themselves and anything else that wasn’t nailed down. Buffalo had never seen a local band play and act with such abandon.

“We sounded horrible,” Johnny admits. “But we were louder, faster and crazier than anybody else.”

No money was coming in, but the Dolls became kings of downtown Buffalo’s new alternative scene. The Goos hit the road with Kwitchoff in a battered old van for a cross-country tour. The van had no windows, a mattress for sleeping, and the food money was $5 a day.

During the tour, a talent scout from Metal Blade Records, a subsidiary of Warner Bros., saw the Dolls play in Los Angeles. He signed the band to the metal label, even though the Goo Goo Dolls were not a metal band.

“We didn’t want to sign, but no one else wanted us,” Robby says.

The Dolls recorded an album called “Jed” that came out in early 1989 and sold about 15,000 copies. The band was touring, recording and selling records, but still not making any money.

In 1991 the Dolls’ second album, “Hold Me Up,” came out on Metal Blade and sold around 60,000 copies. Then, a year later, the band recorded a song for the soundtrack of the horror movie “Freddy’s Dead,” part of the “Nightmare on Elm Street” series. During this period, the Goo Goos also toured with the Replacements and began building a national reputation.

Despite the increased notoriety and record sales, money was still a problem. The band sensed it needed a national management firm, and Kwitchoff agreed.

“I knew they needed a big-time management firm to get to the next level,” Kwitchoff says. “In the record business you’ve got to have management that can pull strings to get the big labels and powerful people.”

The Dolls signed with Roven-Covallo, a Los Angeles agency that handles Prince and Paula Abdul, among other rock stars.

“We were their first alternative band,” Johnny says. “They were used to pushing these big stars and an alternative act was harder to work. But then a couple of years ago Nirvana hit it big, and everything changed.”

Pat Magnarella, part of the Goo Goo Dolls’ management team in Los Angeles, says: “This is a band that has been going up step by step. Now they’ve made a great record. Warner Bros. loves it. We’ve had a good response from radio stations. The band has done everything it can; it’s just a matter of waiting to see what happens. You just never know.”

The Goo Goo Dolls spent over a year working on “Superstar Car Wash” with producer Gavin MacKillop. He comes from Scotland and recently produced a hit record for Toad the Wet Sprocket.

MacKillop says: “The core of this band is the spirit of its live performance. That’s what makes them special, and that’s what we wanted to capture. Individually, they are three very different people. But collectively, when they come together, something special happens.”

Regardless of the album’s success, the Goo Goo Dolls have already changed. The wild young rockers have evolved into men, made wiser by the business of rock ‘n’ roll.

“In a way, it’s a good thing that things didn’t happen overnight for us,” Johnny says. “I mean, if we had come out of nowhere and became stars, it would have freaked us out.

“We made a lot of mistakes because we’d do anything to make music. We’ve changed. We took control of our careers. I mean, we’re getting in our late 20s, we’ve got one foot in the rock ‘n’ roll grave. We figured it was time to take control of our career.”

The band has realistic expectations for the future.

“I never had any delusions of being a rock ‘n’ roll millionaire,” George says. “To me it’s a job, a way to make a living like my father makes a living. And if I can make a living playing rock ‘n’ roll, I’m happy.”

Johnny’s says: “There’s no such thing as rock ‘n’ roll stardom. Bands are disposable. They come and they go.”

So what has kept the Goo Goo Dolls together?

“Stupidity,” says Marcel Thimot, a friend who has worked and toured with the band for about five years. “I mean, what else can the Goo Goo Dolls do besides rock ‘n’ roll?”

Thimot laughs, pauses, and then turns unexpectedly serious. “The reason this band still exists is because they really love each other,” he says.

Artie Kwitchoff agrees. “I think their spirit and friendship comes through in their work. They fight a lot, but they need each other. They sing about life and real-life relationships. They’re crazy, but there’s something about them that touches people.

“Believe me, they’ve been through total hell. This is a band that had to grow out of its own madness. Now their time has come.”

Taken from here. Archived version here.